The Comedy Cellar in Greenwich Village is the best comedy club in New York City for most visitors — it is the room where Dave Chappelle, Chris Rock, and Amy Schumer drop in unannounced. For a more upscale, predictable night out, Gotham Comedy Club on West 22nd Street is the top alternative. Budget $50–$80 per person including the two-item minimum.
The most prestigious comedy room in America. Legendary drop-in culture, intimate basement setting, and 40+ years of history. Rated 4.8★ with 10,000+ reviews.
Best for groups and date nights. Polished full-service club with scheduled national headliners, better food, and a more comfortable room.
The Cellar is where legends perform. Gotham is where you take your boss.
The most important comedy room in the country. No other club matches its combination of prestige, surprise drop-ins, and consistent quality.
Central Midtown location, clear ticketing, reliable headliners every night, and a full dinner menu. No insider knowledge required.
Multiple shows nightly, affordable tickets, and a rotating cast of NYC-based comics. The best room for discovering the next generation.
Full dinner service, reserved seating, and a polished atmosphere make it the most date-friendly comedy club in the city.
Multiple open mic nights weekly in a real club setting. One of the most active open mic programs in the city.
No other club in the world has a more active celebrity drop-in culture. Chappelle, Rock, and Seinfeld have all walked in unannounced.
For tourists visiting New York City, the Comedy Cellar (Village Underground location) and Gotham Comedy Club offer the most reliable headliner experiences without requiring insider knowledge. Both venues have clear ticketing, central locations, and nightly shows featuring nationally touring comedians. Book at least 48 hours in advance on weekends — both venues sell out regularly.
362 Grand Street
Flop House Comedy Club was founded by comedian Nicholas Hopping and his brother Nathan Hopping to ensure an inviting experience featuring AMAZING lineups, affordable tickets, no drink minimums, and comedians from Netflix, HBO and more.
1118 1st Avenue
Rodney’s is the re-imagination and redesign of the legendary Dangerfields, the oldest comedy club in the US. Located on the historic stage in the Upper East Side, Rodney’s is bringing back classic New York stand-up comedy with a modern twist.
117 Minetta Lane
The Comedy Cellar at 117 Minetta Lane is the most famous comedy club in the world. Founded in 1982 beneath the Olive Tree Cafe in Greenwich Village, it is the room where Dave Chappelle, Chris Rock, Jerry Seinfeld, and Amy Schumer perform unannounced on a regular basis. The club runs two shows nightly, seven days a week, with a lineup that is never announced in advance — you pay for the room, not a specific comedian. That policy is the reason the best comedians in the world use it as a workshop. The room seats approximately 110 people at small cabaret tables with a clear sightline to a brick-wall stage. A two-item minimum (food or drinks) is enforced. The club also operates the Village Underground at 130 W 3rd Street, a slightly larger room with the same booking philosophy. Tickets are released on Monday mornings for the following week; weekend shows sell out within hours.
| Venue | Best For | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Comedy Cellar | Celebrity drop-ins, serious fans | $20–$30 + 2-item min |
| Gotham Comedy Club | Date night, groups, tourists | $18–$35 + 2-item min |
| The Stand NYC | Locals, rising comics | $20–$35 |
| Carolines on Broadway | National touring headliners | $22–$40 |
| New York Comedy Club | Open mic, budget nights | $15–$35 |
| Comic Strip Live | Upper East Side locals | $30–$60 |
| Vibe | Intimate basement room, legendary drop-in culture |
| Price | $20–$30 + 2-item minimum |
| Best for | Surprise celebrity drop-ins, serious comedy fans |
| Headliners | Frequent unannounced drop-ins from top names |
| Open Mic | No |
| Vibe | Upscale full-service club, polished production |
| Price | $18–$35 + 2-item minimum |
| Best for | Date nights, groups, reliable headliner shows |
| Headliners | Scheduled national touring headliners |
| Open Mic | Yes |
Verdict: The Comedy Cellar wins on prestige and spontaneity — it is the room that defines New York comedy. Gotham Comedy Club wins on comfort, service, and predictability. If you want the chance to see a legend walk in unannounced, choose the Cellar. If you want a guaranteed great show in a nicer room with dinner, choose Gotham.
The Comedy Cellar is the more prestigious room — intimate, unpredictable, and the only club in the world where Dave Chappelle or Chris Rock might walk in unannounced. Gotham Comedy Club is the more comfortable night out — polished production, announced headliners, and a full dinner service. First-timers who want a guaranteed great show should choose Gotham. Serious comedy fans who want the best possible experience should choose the Cellar. Both enforce a two-item minimum. Full comparison: Gotham vs. Comedy Cellar.
Carolines is the better choice when you want to see a specific touring comedian — the lineup is announced, the room is larger, and the Times Square location is convenient for visitors. The Comedy Cellar is the better choice when you want the best possible stand-up experience without a guaranteed name. Carolines costs more ($22–$50 per ticket vs. $10–$25 at the Cellar) and has less of the drop-in culture that makes the Cellar famous.
The Stand NYC is the best option for locals who want to see comedy regularly without paying Cellar prices. Tickets run $15–$25 with no two-item minimum at some shows, and the club books strong working comedians nightly. The Cellar is the better choice for a special occasion or a first visit to NYC comedy. For a regular Tuesday night out, The Stand is the more practical pick.
Comedy Cellar and Gotham both sell out on weekends — book at least 3 days ahead. The Cellar releases tickets at 9am Mondays for the following week. Carolines is the easiest walk-in option for last-minute plans.
Flop House Comedy Club was founded by comedian Nicholas Hopping and his brother Nathan Hopping to ensure an inviting experience featuring AMAZING lineups, affordable tickets, no drink minimums, and comedians from Netflix, HBO and more.
Rodney’s is the re-imagination and redesign of the legendary Dangerfields, the oldest comedy club in the US. Located on the historic stage in the Upper East Side, Rodney’s is bringing back classic New York stand-up comedy with a modern twist.
The Comedy Cellar at 117 Minetta Lane is the most famous comedy club in the world. Founded in 1982 beneath the Olive Tree Cafe in Greenwich Village, it is the room where Dave Chappelle, Chris Rock, Jerry Seinfeld, and Amy Schumer perform unannounced on a regular basis. The club runs two shows nightly, seven days a week, with a lineup that is never announced in advance — you pay for the room, not a specific comedian. That policy is the reason the best comedians in the world use it as a workshop. The room seats approximately 110 people at small cabaret tables with a clear sightline to a brick-wall stage. A two-item minimum (food or drinks) is enforced. The club also operates the Village Underground at 130 W 3rd Street, a slightly larger room with the same booking philosophy. Tickets are released on Monday mornings for the following week; weekend shows sell out within hours.
The Village Underground at 130 W 3rd Street is the second room operated by Comedy Cellar, located one block from the main MacDougal Street location. The room is slightly larger than the original Cellar (approximately 150 seats) and operates with the same booking philosophy — no announced lineup, same caliber of comedians, same two-item minimum. If the main Comedy Cellar is sold out, the Village Underground is the next best option for the same experience. The room has a more modern feel than the basement Cellar but maintains the same intimate atmosphere and the same possibility of a celebrity drop-in.
Magnet Theater is a performance space and training ground for the best and brightest comedic talent in New York City. Since 2005, we’ve been at the epicenter of the city’s growing improv movement—and today, we’re one of the most recognizable improv schools and theaters in the city.
Asylum NYC is your go-to destination for live comedy in New York City. Whether you’re into high-energy improv, razor-sharp stand-up, creative sketch comedy, or wild variety acts, our stage has it all.
We deliver the quintessential New York stand-up comedy experience: a comic, a mic, a brick wall, and room packed with fans. At our clubs, rising stars share the stage with the biggest names in comedy.
The Upright Citizens Brigade is home for all things comedy. With shows seven nights a week, UCB has become the home for alternative comedy — improv, sketch, stand-up, and yes, all the wonderfully weird shit in between.
The Peoples Improv Theater is an award winning training center and comedy theater based in New York City.
Gotham Comedy Club at 208 W 23rd Street in Chelsea is New York City's most polished stand-up experience. Founded in 1996, the club has produced multiple Comedy Central specials and is known for consistently booking nationally touring headliners with announced lineups. The room seats approximately 300 people with excellent sightlines from every seat, full dinner service, and high production values. Unlike the Comedy Cellar, Gotham announces its lineup in advance — you know exactly who you're seeing before you buy tickets. The club is the best choice in NYC for a date night, a special occasion, or a first-time visitor who wants a guaranteed quality experience. Tickets run $18–$35 plus a two-item minimum. Shows run Thursday through Sunday, with weekend shows selling out in advance.
With unbelievable food and the best stand-up comics in New York City, you don’t want to miss a night at The Stand. Since 2012.
West Side Comedy Club has quickly become a go-to spot for top notch talent with a mix of up-and-comers and celebrity talent such as Bill Burr, Ronnie Chieng, Jessica Kirson and so much more. Located in the charming historic Upper West Side, the club has quickly become known for its hilarious lineups, delicious Mexican fare, and Margharita’s that can’t be beat (full dinner menu offered).
Carolines on Broadway at 1626 Broadway is New York City's premier venue for major touring comedians. Founded in 1982 and relocated to its current Times Square location in 1992, Carolines has hosted virtually every major name in American stand-up comedy. The room seats approximately 300 people with a traditional theater-style layout. When a comedian is on a national tour and wants a New York date, Carolines is typically where they play. The tradeoff is intimacy — the room is larger and more theater-like than the Comedy Cellar or Gotham — but for seeing a specific comedian you love, it is the most reliable option in the city. Tickets run $22–$50 depending on the headliner.
Comic Strip Live is the longest running showcase comedy club in the world, let alone a Manhattan comedic institution/insane asylum.
We deliver the quintessential New York stand-up comedy experience: a comic, a mic, a brick wall, and room packed with fans.
We deliver the quintessential New York stand-up comedy experience: a comic, a mic, a brick wall, and room packed with fans.
St. Mark's Comedy Club is a stand-up comedy club in New York, New York. This New York venue hosts regular open mic nights alongside headliner shows, with tickets from $6-$20. 21+ admission policy. Find show schedules, tickets, and venue details on ComedyClubFinder.
Standing Room Comedy Club is a stand-up comedy club in New York, New York. This New York venue features local and touring comedians. Find show schedules, tickets, and venue details on ComedyClubFinder.
Stand Up NY at 221 W 46th Street has been one of New York City's most accessible comedy clubs since 1986. Located in the Theater District near Times Square, it is the most tourist-friendly major comedy club in the city — easy to find, centrally located, and with a welcoming atmosphere for first-time visitors. The club books a mix of local NYC comedians and national touring acts, with shows running most nights of the week. Tickets run $20–$40 with a two-item minimum. Age policy is 16+ with a guardian, 18+ without. Stand Up NY is the best option for tourists who want a reliable comedy night without the advance planning required at the Comedy Cellar or Gotham.
Broadway Comedy Club is the best comedy in New York City with 2 beautiful showrooms in the heart of the Theater District.
Greenwich Village Comedy Club is a stand-up comedy club in New York, New York. This New York venue features local and touring comedians. Find show schedules, tickets, and venue details on ComedyClubFinder.
LOL Times Square Comedy Club is a stand-up comedy club in New York, New York. This New York venue features local and touring comedians. Find show schedules, tickets, and venue details on ComedyClubFinder.
New York's top comedy clubs set the standard for the rest of the country. The Comedy Cellar, Gotham Comedy Club, and Caroline's on Broadway have all shaped what modern stand-up looks like. Crowds here are sharp, experienced, and not easily impressed, which means the comedians who thrive in New York are genuinely excellent. Expect polished sets, surprise drop-ins, and a room that knows comedy.
Rankings based on Google review score, review volume, venue longevity, and editorial assessment of comedy scene significance. No paid placements. Last reviewed April 2026.
The Comedy Cellar in Greenwich Village is consistently ranked the best comedy club in New York City. It has hosted unannounced sets from Dave Chappelle, Chris Rock, Louis C.K., and Amy Schumer. The Village Underground location offers the same lineup in a slightly larger room. For a more upscale experience, Gotham Comedy Club on West 22nd Street is the top alternative.
The Comedy Cellar has the strongest reputation of any comedy club in New York City, built over four decades as the proving ground for American stand-up comedy. It is the club most frequently cited by comedians themselves as the room that matters. Carolines on Broadway and Gotham Comedy Club also carry strong reputations for consistently booking nationally recognized headliners.
For tourists, Gotham Comedy Club and the Comedy Cellar Village Underground location offer the most accessible and reliable experiences. Both venues have clear ticketing, central locations, and nightly shows featuring nationally touring comedians. Book in advance on weekends — shows sell out. Avoid walk-up-only clubs in Times Square, which tend to book lesser-known acts at inflated prices.
It depends on what you're looking for. The Comedy Cellar is the more prestigious room with a legendary drop-in culture — you might see a major celebrity perform unannounced. Gotham Comedy Club offers a more polished, upscale experience with scheduled headliners and better food service. For a first visit to NYC comedy, the Comedy Cellar is the iconic choice; for a date night or group outing, Gotham is more comfortable.
Most NYC comedy clubs charge a ticket price of $20–$40 plus a two-item minimum (food or drinks, typically $10–$20 per person). The Comedy Cellar charges $20–$30 per ticket plus a two-drink minimum. Gotham Comedy Club tickets run $18–$35 with a two-item minimum. Budget approximately $50–$80 per person including drinks for a typical night out at a major NYC comedy club.
Verified venue data
All 22 venues verified against official websites and Google Business Profiles. We check for closures, address changes, and policy updates quarterly.
Real ratings from Google
Star ratings and review counts are sourced directly from Google Places — not estimated or fabricated. Only venues with a Google Business Profile listing are shown.
Last reviewed: April 2026
ComedyClubFinder reviews and updates venue data quarterly. Closed venues are removed; new venues are added as they open. If you spot an error, use the "Report an issue" link on each venue page.
No paid placements
Venue rankings and listings are based entirely on data quality, Google ratings, and completeness — not advertising spend. No club has paid to appear on ComedyClubFinder.